Book Review: Stolen Focus: Why You Can’t Pay Attention—and How to Think Deeply Again by Johann Hari

By Christine MacIntyre

In an age characterized by ceaseless distractions and a relentless assault on our attention spans, Johann Hari’s thought-provoking work, Stolen Focus: Why You Can’t Pay Attention—and How to Think Deeply Again, emerges as a timely and illuminating exploration of the modern cognitive landscape. In a world where the stimulating call of smartphones, social media, and constant connectivity beckons incessantly, Hari navigates the turbulent seas of our digital age with insight and personal resonance. The narrative provides astute observations, practical wisdom, and the hope that we can reclaim the ability to think deeply and engage meaningfully in our world.

Hari contemplated a disquieting notion: the pervasive inability to direct our attention toward significant matters has insidiously encroached on society, akin to an invisible itching powder set upon us, compelling everyone’s minds to convulse and sway. Determined to unravel the enigma of society’s dwindling attention spans, he embarked on a sweeping quest, engaging in conversations with luminaries spanning 30,000 miles, driven by the desire to lift the veil shrouding what he perceives as a systemic quandary—one formerly ascribed to individual shortcomings or the advent of ubiquitous cell phones. Instead, his journey led him to unearth a sprawling and intricate ecosystem perpetuating the pervasive inability to focus

Hari, not an expert himself, operates as a journalist who diligently seeks insights from experts and then adeptly translates their knowledge for readers. Supported by an extensive collection of over 400 online endnotes referencing more than 250 scientific studies, his work emerges as a compelling and authoritative exploration. In his thought-provoking endeavor, he prompts readers to ponder a critical question: Should the defining mantra of our time be, “I tried to live but got distracted?”

The book unfolds as a captivating personal journey, with each chapter gently beckoning readers to uncover discoveries alongside Hari. Readers will likely find themselves forging connections with their experiences, nodding in agreement or recognition. Hari doesn’t adopt a lofty stance; instead, he candidly acknowledges his struggles with focus, providing relatable examples. The narrative elucidates the challenging modern landscape where sustaining deep concentration becomes increasingly elusive, weaving a complex tapestry of contributing factors. However, amid these revelations, Hari offers compelling evidence that change is possible and within our grasp. The idea that the fragmentation of attention has repercussions for individuals and society emphasizes the crucial need to comprehend the underlying dynamics and reasons behind this phenomenon.

Throughout Stolen Focus, Hari meticulously dissects 12 underlying causes contributing to society’s collective struggle with focus across 14 comprehensive chapters. Within this intricate exploration, he identifies these causes and sheds light on potential solutions that delve deeper into the issues at hand. These causes encompass a range of contemporary challenges, including the hindrance of flow states, the disturbance of mind-wandering, the ascent of what he terms “cruel optimism,” the surge in stress and its impact on vigilance, as well as the detrimental effects of our changing diets and escalating pollution levels.

Hari’s book exposes startling facts, like the fact that people interact with their phones 2,617 times daily, symbolic of the digital age’s impact on our lives. While the internet accelerated declining focus, it’s not the sole culprit. Our frenetic modern lives inundate us with information, challenging our concentration ability. Hari dispels the multitasking myth, asserting that our minds are wired for one or two simultaneous thoughts at most. Straining for more overwhelms our cognitive capacity, exacerbated by constant mental filtering, disconnecting us from the present and hindering deep thinking.

Furthermore, the notion that mind-wandering is inherently detrimental is another misconception Hari explores. He argues that when the mind wanders freely, it often forges unexpected connections and can lead to innovative problem-solving. Ironically, the crisis of losing the ability to mind-wander freely can be just as detrimental as the crisis of losing focused attention.

In Stolen Focus, a vicious cycle emerges, with people seeking relief from business through distraction or from distraction through rest, which further erodes their focus. Hari aptly encapsulates this dilemma, noting that “we live in a gap between what we know we should do and what we feel we can do.” Importantly, readers also discover that they aren’t solely responsible for their inability to pay attention. Hari proposes that “there are six ways in which our technology, as it currently works, is harming our ability to pay attention—and that these causes are united by one deeper underlying force that needs to be overcome.” The text conveys a theme: people are becoming less rational, less intelligent, and less focused because of the “collective downgrading of humans and the upgrading of machines.”

Once readers grasp the core issue of the collective struggle with focus, Hari offers a glimmer of hope by suggesting that this challenge isn’t solely an individual burden but rather a shared endeavor to reclaim stolen time, space, rest, sleep, and attention. Solutions lie in challenging the status quo, challenging societal conventions, and refusing to perpetuate the struggle. In concluding this narrative, Hari acknowledges that Stolen Focus isn’t a self-help book, and the complexity of the issue requires an admission—that he, like many of us, hasn’t entirely solved this problem within himself.

The collapse of Hari’s focus mirrors the challenges of society at large, where sleep deprivation and overwork have become prevalent. We constantly switch tasks, besieged by social media’s manipulative infinite scrolling, and stress has rendered us hypervigilant. When readers confront these factors, they gain insights into why their ability to focus has waned and the initial steps toward addressing it.

Read Related Articles: